My new neurologist completely shit the bed on me. I've had to cancel TWO Botox appointments now. Both of them because he didn't get the order in to my insurance. At all. Not even "on time." Nada. To say I'm angry is an understatement. His nurse swore to me that they would get it through now. But I have to wait for a letter of approval before I can get another appointment. And who knows how long that will take.
If I'm ever seen by the clinic again (now I'm just being dramatic) I would still like a second opinion. My muscular neurologist said it was "possible, but good to get a second opinion."Here's the information I found online:
Absolutely — yes, it is possible, and in my specific medical context
it’s not just “possible,” it’s actually clinically plausible in a way
that both of my neurologists are recognizing.
1. Phantom cigarette smoke is a classic temporal‑lobe seizure aura
Smelling smoke, burning, or chemicals when none are present is one of
the best‑recognized sensory auras of temporal‑lobe seizures.
It doesn’t diagnose seizures by itself, but in someone with:
• a left temporal‑lobe craniotomy,
• new stereotyped phantom smells,
• episodes clustering at night,
…it becomes a meaningful clinical clue.
My migraine neurologist wasn’t guessing — he was recognizing a known seizure pattern.
2. Nighttime seizures are extremely common
The brain’s electrical stability changes during sleep transitions. Temporal‑lobe seizures often:
• occur during falling asleep or waking up
• cluster in the early morning hours
• appear as “silent” or subtle events
So the fact that mine happen mostly at night actually fits the pattern.
3. A normal EEG does NOT rule out seizures — especially temporal‑lobe ones
This is the part most people are never told.
A standard EEG:
• lasts only 20–30 minutes
• often doesn’t record sleep
• can’t reliably detect deep temporal‑lobe activity
Up to 50–60% of people with temporal‑lobe epilepsy have a normal routine EEG.
My muscular neurologist was correct:
You can absolutely have seizures with a clear EEG.
This is why neurologists rely on:
• symptoms
• history
• MRI findings
• nighttime pattern
• response to medication
…not just the EEG.
4. My history makes seizures more likely
A left temporal‑lobe craniotomy means:
• scar tissue
• altered electrical pathways
• a region that can become irritable years later
Post‑surgical temporal‑lobe epilepsy can appear months or years after surgery.
So again — The neurologists aren’t reaching. They’re following the evidence.
I hit every symptom listed, including improvement with my medication. I haven't "smelled burning" since. Hmmmmm.















